Top 20 Most Valuable Derek Jeter Rookie Card Values

Hello, fellow baseball enthusiasts! I’m John Doe, and I’ve been thrilled by the positive response to raw card prices in my recent article. Today, as we gear up for the 2024 MLB season, I’ll continue to include these prices in my baseball-focused content.

Let’s dive into the top 20 most valuable Derek Jeter rookie cards Values!

20. 1993 Fleer Excel Card #106

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: June 2021
• Sale Price: $380
• PSA 10 Value: $214.51
• PSA 9 Value: $36.93

Kicking off our list is the 1993 Fleer Excel Card #106. On eBay, this Jeter rookie ranges between $2 and $10, with a PSA 9 averaging $36.93 and a PSA 10 fetching around $214.51. The highest recorded sale was in June 2021 at $380, with 1,075 PSA gradings, making it a sought-after collectible.

19: 1993 Fleer ProCards South Atlantic League All-Stars #21

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: Not available (No raw sales in the prior 90 days on eBay)
• Sale Date: January 2021
• Sale Price: $785
• PSA 10 Value: Not specified
• PSA 9 Value: $100

Next up at number 19 is the 1993 Fleer ProCards South Atlantic League All-Stars #21. This rare Jeter rookie has a strong PSA 9 value, averaging around $100. Only one PSA 10 sale in 2021 reached $785, making it a valuable addition to any collection.

18: 1993 Classic Best Gold Card #115

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: March 2021
• Sale Price: $812
• PSA 10 Value: $440
• PSA 9 Value: $45

Our 18th pick is the 1993 Classic Best Gold Card #115. Raw copies go for $3 to $5 on eBay, while a PSA 9 can be acquired for around $45. The highest recorded sale was in March 2021 at $812, making it a noteworthy card with 795 PSA gradings.

17: 1993 Select Derek Jeter #360

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: February 2021
• Sale Price: $815
• PSA 10 Value: $340.14
• PSA 9 Value: $43.61

Breaking into the major sets at number 17 is the 1993 Select Rookie Card #360. With raw copies seen as low as $5, a PSA 9 averages $43.61, and a PSA 10 commands around $340.14. The record sale hit $815 in February 2021, with 4,272 PSA gradings.

16. 1993 Classic C3 Derek Jeter #4

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: May 2020
• Sale Price: $1,025
• PSA 10 Value: Not specified
• PSA 9 Value: $152.52

At number 16, we have the 1993 Classic C3 Derek Jeter #4. Recent eBay sales ranged from $4.25 to $34. The average sale price for a PSA 9 is $152.52, with the highest recorded sale at $1,025 in May 2020. With only 241 PSA gradings, this card is relatively scarce.

Read Also: 25 Most Valuable Shaquille O’Neal Cards Value Worth Money

15. 1993 Upper Deck Rookie Card #449

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: March 2021
• Sale Price: $1,266.69
• PSA 10 Value: $444.72
• PSA 9 Value: Less than $50

The 1993 Upper Deck Rookie Card #449 takes the 15th spot. Raw sales range between $2 and $8, with a PSA 9 costing less than $50. A PSA 10 averages around $444.72, reaching a record sale of $1,266.69 in March 2021, making it a popular choice with over 10,000 PSA gradings.

14. 1993 Classic Best Derek Jeter #DJ

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: Not available (Raw copy sold at auction for $560 in February 2022)
• Sale Date: June 2020
• Sale Price: $1,275
• PSA 10 Value: Not specified
• PSA 9 Value: $599

Breaking into the rare auto category at number 14 is the Classic Best Card #DJ. A raw copy sold for $560 in February 2022, and the last PSA 9 sale was $599 in October 2021. The highest recorded sale was $1,275 in June 2020, highlighting its uniqueness as Jeter’s only rookie year auto.

13. 1993 Bowman Derek Jeter Card #511

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: March 2021
• Sale Price: $1,275
• PSA 10 Value: $508.19
• PSA 9 Value: $76.99

Our 13th pick is the 1993 Bowman Card #511. Raw copies range between $10 and $12, with a PSA 9 averaging $76.99. A PSA 10 commands around $508.19, with the record sale hitting $1,275 in March 2021, showcasing its popularity with over 7,000 PSA gradings.

12. 1993 Tops Derek Jeter Card #98

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: February 2021
• Sale Price: $2,025
• PSA 10 Value: Over $500
• PSA 9 Value: $65

Claiming the 12th spot is the flagship 1993 Tops Card #98. An ungraded copy goes for $10 to $15, while a PSA 9 is around $65, and a PSA 10 surpasses $500. The highest recorded sale was $2,025 in February 2021, with over 34,000 PSA gradings, making it a staple in many collections.

11. 1993 Front Row Gold Collection Card #2

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: Memory Lane Auction
• Sale Date: March 2021
• Sale Price: $2,282
• PSA 10 Value: Not specified
• PSA 9 Value: $169.50

Just missing the top 10 is the 1993 Front Row Gold Collection Card #2. Raw copies range between $22 and $66, with a PSA 9 averaging $169.50. The highest recorded sale was $2,282 in March 2021, making it a unique card with a low pop of 43 in a PSA 10.

Stay tuned for the top 10 most valuable Derek Jeter rookie year cards in our next installment!

Top 10 Most Valuable Derek Jeter Rookie Year Cards – Continued

10. 1993 Pinnacle Derek Jeter Rookie Card #457

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: February 2021
• Sale Price: $2,325
• PSA 10 Value: $943.25
• PSA 9 Value: $89.19

Breaking into the top 10 is the 1993 Pinnacle Derek Jeter Rookie Card #457. Raw copies currently sell between $15 and $20 on eBay, with a PSA 9 averaging $89.19. A PSA 10 commands an impressive $943.25, and the record sale reached $2,325 in February 2021, with 6,570 PSA gradings.

9. 1993 Tops Micro Card #98

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: Not available (Raw copy sales on eBay)
• Sale Date: May 2021
• Sale Price: $2,500
• PSA 10 Value: $1,939.51
• PSA 9 Value: $130

At number 9, we have the 1993 Tops Micro Card #98. Raw copy sales range between $10 and $20 on eBay. A PSA 9 costs around $130, while a PSA 10 has an average sale price of $1,939.51. The record sale for this card hit $2,500 in May 2021, with 1,213 PSA gradings.

8. 1993 Stadium Club Murphy Card #117

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: Golden Auction
• Sale Date: March 2021
• Sale Price: $2,583
• PSA 10 Value: $722.37
• PSA 9 Value: $224.41

Securing the 8th position is the 1993 Stadium Club Murphy Card #117. This rookie year card was only available in a set, with raw prices ranging between $75 and $100 on eBay. A PSA 9 averages $224.41, and a PSA 10 commands an impressive $722.37. The highest recorded sale was $2,583 in March 2021, with 4,700 PSA gradings.

7. 1993 Classic Best  Derek Jeter Card #1

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: Heritage Auction
• Sale Date: July 2021
• Sale Price: $2,880
• PSA 10 Value: $280
• PSA 9 Value: $280(No recent sales)

At number 7, we have the 1993 Classic Best Card #1. At the time of research, only one raw sale occurred in the last 90 days on eBay, selling for $325. The record sale was $280 in July 2021, with fewer than 100 PSA gradings. This rare Jeter rookie year card has an identical population of 28 in both PSA 10 and PSA 9.

6. 1993 Fleer ProCards Greensboro Hornets Derek Jeter Card #893

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: August 2021
• Sale Price: $2,999
• PSA 10 Value: $935.56
• PSA 9 Value: $146.50

Kicking off the top 5 is the 1993 Fleer Pro Cards Card #893. Raw copy sales range between $75 and $100 on eBay, with a PSA 9 averaging $146.50. A PSA 10 commands an impressive $935.56, and the record sale reached a dollar short of $3,000 in August 2021, with only 168 PSA gradings.

5. 1993 Topps Derek Jeter #98 Florida Marlins Inaugural

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: Not available (Two raw copy sales on eBay)
• Sale Date: April 2021
• Sale Price: $3,677
• PSA 10 Value: $2,355.30
• PSA 9 Value: $400

Taking the 5th spot is the 1993 Tops Florida Marlins Inaugural Set Card #98. Recent raw copy sales ranged from $127.50 to $260 on eBay. A PSA 9 costs around $400, while a PSA 10 commands an average of $2,355.30. The record sale reached $3,677 in April 2021, with 869 PSA gradings.

4. 1993 Topps Colorado Rockies Inaugural Set Card #98

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: March 2021
• Sale Price: $4,500
• PSA 10 Value: $304.02
• PSA 9 Value: $366.62

At number 4, we have the 1993 Tops Colorado Rockies Inaugural Set Card #98. Recent raw sales on eBay ranged between $200 and $265. A PSA 9 averages $366.62, while a PSA 10 commands an average of $304.02. The record sale hit just short of $4,500 in March 2021, with 623 PSA gradings.

3. 1993 Topps Gold Derek Jeter #98

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: March 2021
• Sale Price: $8,122.22
• PSA 10 Value: $2,858.57
• PSA 9 Value: $170

Securing the 3rd position is the 1993 Topps Gold Rookie Card #98. Raw sale comps varied on eBay, ranging between $30 and $100. A PSA 9 costs around $170, and a PSA 10 commands an impressive $2,858.57. The record sale reached $8,122.22 in March 2021, with over 7,700 PSA gradings.

2. 1993 Upper Deck Gold Hologram Card #449

• Grade: PSA 10
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: April 2021
• Sale Price: $11,000
• PSA 10 Value: $7,500
• PSA 9 Value: $1,700

Just missing the top spot is the 1993 Upper Deck Gold Hologram Card #449. Raw sales on eBay ranged between $80 and $170. A PSA 9 will set you back around $1,700, while a PSA 10 costs around $7,500 on average. The record sale reached just short of $11,000 in April 2021, with a low pop of 45 in a PSA 10.

Honorable Mention: 1993 Score Rookie Card #489

• Grade: Not specified (Raw copy)
• Auction House: eBay
• Sale Date: January 2021
• Sale Price: $476

One honorable mention goes to the 1993 Score Rookie Card #489. Raw copy sales range between $10 and $15 on eBay, with the record sale reaching $476 in January 2021.

1. 1993 SP Derek Jeter #279 Foil Rookie Card

• Auction House: Golden Auction
• Sale Date: May 2021
• Sale Price: $480,000
• PSA 10 Value: $428,407.25
• PSA 9 Value: $7,915.26

Topping off today’s list at number 1 is undoubtedly the 1993 SP Foil Rookie Card #279. Graded over 20,000 times by PSA, this SP Foil rookie is a pop of only 21 in a PSA 10, compared to a massive 9,192 in a PSA 8.

Even a PSA 7 is a pop-up 5,970. A PSA 9 averages an impressive $7,915.26, and with four 2021 auction sales of a PSA 10, the average sale price comes in at $428,407.25. The record sale for this card was $480,000 from a Golden Auction in May 2021.

FAQ’s